← All passagesThe Rhetoric Reader

Passage 190 · 2013

Heroic Cosplay (Tenth of December)

George Saunders · Tenth of December · Opening sentence

hover a marked phrase · click to pin · chips toggle layers
The pale boy with unfortunate prince valiant bangs and cublike mannerisms hulked to the mudroom closet and requisitioned Dad's white coat.
He looked b.a. in it and for a moment even thought about wearing it to school.

Thesis of effectComic diction mash-up—bureaucratic verbs, slang, and tender descriptors—captures the gulf between fantasy and reality.

OccasionIntroduce awkward boy fantasizing heroism before stepping outside.
PersonaClose third-person tethered to imaginative child.

Device index

Hover a card to trace its span in the passage; click to pin its dossier card.

Tropes

IronyEYE-ruh-nee / ˈaɪrəni

Reveals tender self-delusion.

Litotes by implicationLY-tuh-teez / ˈlaɪtətiːz (also lie-TOH-teez)

Underplays social disaster for humor.

Metaphor/AnimalizationMET-uh-for / ˈmɛtəfɔːr

Makes him seem small, tentative.

Hyperbolehy-PER-buh-lee / haɪˈpɜːrbəliː

Exaggerates action to match fantasy.

Schemes

Accumulative modifiersee-noo-mer-AH-tee-oh

Piles comic detail.

not span-anchored
Incongruous verb pairing

Mixes superhero swagger with bureaucratic precision.

Coordinated predicate

Links perception to brief fantasy.

Temporal clause

Limits duration of confidence.

Syntax

Free indirect style tint(FID)

Blends boy’s voice with narrator.

Cinematic movement

Visualizes boy playing hero.

Causal sequencing

Shows thought emerging from pretend play.

not span-anchored

Full dossier

1Ear & Prosody

Mouthfeel: Mix of soft vowels (pale, boy) and percussive consonants (prince, bangs) for comic rhythm.

Cadence: L1 long, tumbling; L2 shorter with beat drop at "b.a." and "for a moment."

Music: Feels like theme song swelling then cutting abruptly.

2Syntax As Style (Tufte-grade)

Sentence shape:
- L1: Subject + adjective stack + compound predicate.
- L2: Simple clause with coordinated infinitive phrase.

Modification choreography:
- Preposed: "The pale boy" establishes archetype.
- Mid: Embedded modifiers describe hair/mannerisms.
- Postposed: Coordinated verbs deliver actions; "Dad's white coat" grounds scene.

Coordination/subordination ratio: Coordination heavy; only brief prepositional subordination.

Information flow: Physical description → dramatic action → self-evaluation → fleeting daydream.

Micro-rewrites:
- Compressed: "A pale, awkward boy trudged to the closet, took his dad’s coat, felt cool, and considered wearing it to school." — Efficient but loses humorous diction.
- Dilated: "The pale boy, saddled with prince Valiant bangs and cublike habits, hulked to the mudroom closet and requisitioned his dad’s lab coat; he felt extremely badass in it and, for a fleeting instant, imagined showing up to school draped in its authority." — Keeps comedy while elaborating.

3Deixis, Aspect, Modality

Deixis: Definite "The" implies familiarity; "Dad's" signals family intimacy.

Aspect: Simple past for actions; "thought" indicates momentary contemplation.

Modality: "Even" intensifies possibility, highlighting improbability.

Temporal logic: Sequence from action to fantasy within same moment.

4Image System & Field

Metaphor families: Superhero/comic language (hulked, b.a.), military/bureaucratic (requisitioned), animal (cublike).

Lexical fields: Childhood play, fashion, authority.

Image logic: Borrowed adult objects fuel childish hero fantasies while emphasizing vulnerability.

5Narrative Mechanics

Focalization: Third-person limited aligned with boy’s perceptions.

Time: Immediate pre-adventure setup.

Beat structure: Description → appropriation of coat → self-admiration → fleeting plan.

Subtext: Desire for power/control before facing outside world.

6Appeals & Strategy

Ethos: Saunders establishes intimate knowledge of quirky kids.

Pathos: Reader empathizes with boy’s yearning for confidence.

Logos: Syntax logically connects costume acquisition to fantasy.

7Lineage & Kinships

Comic realism: Echoes Lorrie Moore’s witty character portraits.

Superhero parody: References Marvel/DC lexicon via "hulked," "b.a.".

Childhood POV: Aligns with Stephen King’s early sections of It capturing awkward bravery.

8Hotspots & Faultlines

Hotspots

  1. "unfortunate prince valiant bangs" — instantly visual comedic detail.
  2. "hulked…requisitioned" — jarring verb mix.
  3. "looked b.a." — reveals inner monologue.

Faultlines

  • Slang abbreviation may date text—intentional to mark youth.
  • Reader may question if "hulked" mocks boy; Saunders balances with empathy.
9Revision Studio

Subtraction test: Remove "cublike"—lose animal vulnerability.

Amplification test: Add sensory detail (coat smell)—could deepen but risk slowing pace.

Register shift:
- Formal: "The pale boy, possessed of unfortunate Prince Valiant bangs, strode to the mudroom closet and appropriated his father’s white coat."
- Colloquial: "This pale kid with Prince Valiant bangs lumbered to the closet and snagged Dad’s coat."

Punctuation swap: Insert em dash before "and requisitioned"—would emphasize verb switch.

10Imitatio / Counter-imitatio

Imitatio: The skinny girl with thrifted cape and flitty hands power-stanced by the mirror and commandeered Mom’s stethoscope.

Counter-Imitatio: A boy took his dad’s coat. — Loses stylistic spark.

Compression (≤25 words): Pale boy with Prince Valiant bangs hulked to the mudroom, requisitioned Dad’s coat, felt b.a., and briefly imagined wearing it to school.

11Steal This (Takeaways)
  1. Pile modifiers to sketch character instantly.
  2. Contrast grandiose verbs with mundane action for humor.
  3. Let slang leak into narration to channel POV.
  4. Use clothing appropriation to signal identity play.
  5. Follow action with thought to show imaginative leap.
  6. Keep tempo brisk via two-sentence structure.
  7. Balance satire with empathy.