RRhetoric
← All passagesThe Rhetoric Reader

Passage 137 · 1891

"A Scandal in Bohemia"

Arthur Conan Doyle · A Scandal in Bohemia · Selected passage

hover or select a marked phrase · click to keep its explanation open
To Sherlock Holmes she is always the woman. I have seldom heard him mention her under any other name. In his eyes she eclipses and predominates the whole of her sex.

Main effectThrough fronted prepositional perspective, copulative eternal present, italicized emphatic article, negative frequency, and compound verbs of dominance over genitive totality, Doyle creates syntax of singular obsession—grammar that performs Holmes's unique regard through categorical linguistic distinction.

Device index

Hover over a device to highlight its words. Select it to keep the explanation open.

Tropes

Italicizationih-tal-ih-sih-ZAY-shun

Typographic emphasis.

Hyperbolehy-PER-buh-lee

Exaggeration.

Metonymymeh-TAH-nuh-mee

Associated term for thing.

Syntax

Prepositional Specification

"To Sherlock Holmes"—prepositional phrase fronted. Syntax emphasizes perspective as personal, not universal.

Copulative Eternality

"she is always the woman"—present tense with frequency adverb. Syntax makes designation timeless.

Emphatic Article

Italicized "the"—definite article given typographic weight. Syntax performs uniqueness through typography.

Negative Frequency

"I have seldom heard"—present perfect with frequency adverb. Syntax emphasizes rarity through negation.

Infinitive Object

"heard him mention her"—complex verb phrase with accusative and infinitive. Syntax shows indirect reporting.

Prepositional Substitute

"under any other name"—prepositional phrase indicating manner. Syntax suggests other names exist but aren't used.

Locative MetaphorMET-uh-for / ˈmɛtəfɔːr

"In his eyes"—prepositional phrase of perception. Syntax makes evaluation visual, observational.

Compound Verb Dominance

"eclipses and predominates"—two verbs coordinated. Syntax doubles the supremacy.

Genitive Totality

"the whole of her sex"—complex genitive. Syntax makes comparison cosmic, categorical.

Close reading

1Close Reading

Prepositional Specification

"To Sherlock Holmes"—prepositional phrase fronted. Syntax emphasizes perspective as personal, not universal.

Copulative Eternality

"she is always the woman"—present tense with frequency adverb. Syntax makes designation timeless.

Emphatic Article

Italicized "the"—definite article given typographic weight. Syntax performs uniqueness through typography.

Negative Frequency

"I have seldom heard"—present perfect with frequency adverb. Syntax emphasizes rarity through negation.

Infinitive Object

"heard him mention her"—complex verb phrase with accusative and infinitive. Syntax shows indirect reporting.

Prepositional Substitute

"under any other name"—prepositional phrase indicating manner. Syntax suggests other names exist but aren't used.

Locative Metaphor

"In his eyes"—prepositional phrase of perception. Syntax makes evaluation visual, observational.

Compound Verb Dominance

"eclipses and predominates"—two verbs coordinated. Syntax doubles the supremacy.

Genitive Totality

"the whole of her sex"—complex genitive. Syntax makes comparison cosmic, categorical.

Stylistic Effect

Through fronted prepositional perspective, copulative eternal present, italicized emphatic article, negative frequency, and compound verbs of dominance over genitive totality, Doyle creates syntax of singular obsession—grammar that performs Holmes's unique regard through categorical linguistic distinction.