RRhetoric
← All passagesThe Rhetoric Reader

Passage 077 · 1940

"Musée des Beaux Arts"

W.H. Auden · Another Time · Selected passage

hover or select a marked phrase · click to keep its explanation open
About suffering they were never wrong,
The Old Masters

Main effectThrough inversion, litotes, and fragmentary syntax, Auden creates conversational profundity—syntax that sounds casual while making absolute claims about art and suffering.

Device index

Hover over a device to highlight its words. Select it to keep the explanation open.

Tropes

LitotesLIE-tuh-teez

Understatement through negation.

Schemes

Inversionin-VER-zhun

Reversal of normal word order.

Syntax

Prepositional Opening

"About suffering"—prepositional phrase fronted before subject creates emphasis through inversion. Topic (suffering) precedes claim.

Negative Construction

"never wrong"—double negative morphology (never + wrong) creates emphatic positive. Syntax through negation paradoxically asserts certainty.

Fragment Effect

"The Old Masters"—noun phrase standing as sentence or fragment. Creates pause, emphasis on who "they" are.

Close reading

1Close Reading

Prepositional Opening

"About suffering"—prepositional phrase fronted before subject creates emphasis through inversion. Topic (suffering) precedes claim.

Negative Construction

"never wrong"—double negative morphology (never + wrong) creates emphatic positive. Syntax through negation paradoxically asserts certainty.

Fragment Effect

"The Old Masters"—noun phrase standing as sentence or fragment. Creates pause, emphasis on who "they" are.

Stylistic Effect

Through inversion, litotes, and fragmentary syntax, Auden creates conversational profundity—syntax that sounds casual while making absolute claims about art and suffering.